How to Calculate Your Win Rate — and Why It's Not the Whole Story
Win rate alone tells you almost nothing. Learn the formula, the trap of incomplete data, and the R-multiple math that pairs with it to describe a real system.
Every trader quotes a win rate; almost none compute it correctly. Here's the formula, the ways it gets quietly corrupted, and the one number you must pair it with.
The win rate formula
Win rate = winning trades ÷ (winning trades + losing trades)
Win means profit strictly greater than zero; loss means profit strictly less than zero. Trades with exactly zero profit are scratch trades and belong in neither bucket.
The three ways win rate gets corrupted
- Open trades in the denominator. An open position has no outcome. Including it deflates your win rate.
- Breakeven trades counted as losses. A scratch at exactly zero is not a loss — it's a non-event. Most journals and spreadsheets lump them wrong.
- Small samples. Ten trades tell you nothing. Win rate stabilizes at roughly 50–100 trades per strategy.
Why win rate alone is meaningless
A 90% win rate that risks 10 to make 1 is a slow catastrophe: (0.9 × 1) − (0.1 × 10) = −0.1 expected value per trade. The complement of win rate is average win size versus average loss size, expressed cleanest as the R-multiple — profit expressed in units of initial risk.
Expectancy = (win rate × average win in R) − (loss rate × average loss in R). Positive expectancy over a large sample is the definition of an edge.
What to actually measure
Track win rate per strategy, not per account. Per-setup win rate answers the useful question: which of my plays deserves more size? And track it against your planned risk — realized versus planned R is the fastest way to see whether you're moving stops out of fear.
Let the math do the work
Hand-computing expectancy across a few hundred trades is where motivation goes to die. This is the whole reason CandlEntry computes win rate, expectancy, and profit factor per setup automatically — synced straight from your broker, with open and scratch trades handled correctly.