Features AI Analyst Brokers How It Works Pricing Sign In Get Started

How to Calculate Your Win Rate — and Why It's Not the Whole Story

Win rate alone tells you almost nothing. Learn the formula, the trap of incomplete data, and the R-multiple math that pairs with it to describe a real system.

Every trader quotes a win rate; almost none compute it correctly. Here's the formula, the ways it gets quietly corrupted, and the one number you must pair it with.

The win rate formula

Win rate = winning trades ÷ (winning trades + losing trades)

Win means profit strictly greater than zero; loss means profit strictly less than zero. Trades with exactly zero profit are scratch trades and belong in neither bucket.

The three ways win rate gets corrupted

  1. Open trades in the denominator. An open position has no outcome. Including it deflates your win rate.
  2. Breakeven trades counted as losses. A scratch at exactly zero is not a loss — it's a non-event. Most journals and spreadsheets lump them wrong.
  3. Small samples. Ten trades tell you nothing. Win rate stabilizes at roughly 50–100 trades per strategy.

Why win rate alone is meaningless

A 90% win rate that risks 10 to make 1 is a slow catastrophe: (0.9 × 1) − (0.1 × 10) = −0.1 expected value per trade. The complement of win rate is average win size versus average loss size, expressed cleanest as the R-multiple — profit expressed in units of initial risk.

Expectancy = (win rate × average win in R) − (loss rate × average loss in R). Positive expectancy over a large sample is the definition of an edge.

What to actually measure

Track win rate per strategy, not per account. Per-setup win rate answers the useful question: which of my plays deserves more size? And track it against your planned risk — realized versus planned R is the fastest way to see whether you're moving stops out of fear.

Let the math do the work

Hand-computing expectancy across a few hundred trades is where motivation goes to die. This is the whole reason CandlEntry computes win rate, expectancy, and profit factor per setup automatically — synced straight from your broker, with open and scratch trades handled correctly.

Back to the Journal